← Back to Blog

Restaurant Upselling Strategies with Digital Menu Boards

The difference between a restaurant that's surviving and one that's thriving often comes down to average ticket size. If you can increase what each customer spends by even $2-3, the impact on monthly revenue is dramatic. Digital menu boards are one of the most effective tools for doing this because they influence purchasing decisions at the exact moment customers are choosing what to order.

Here are proven upselling strategies that work specifically through digital menu boards.

The Psychology of Digital Menu Upselling

Visual Influence

Humans are visual decision-makers. When a customer sees a vivid, appetizing photo of a premium burger on a bright digital screen, the desire to upgrade from the basic option becomes almost automatic. Printed menus can't match the visual impact of a backlit, high-resolution digital display. The food looks better, which makes people willing to spend more.

Anchoring Effect

The anchoring effect is a cognitive bias where people rely heavily on the first piece of information they see. On a digital menu, placing your most expensive item first in each category sets a high anchor. Everything after it seems more reasonable by comparison. A $24 premium steak makes the $16 standard steak feel like a great deal.

The Decoy Effect

Offer three sizes: small ($5), medium ($7), and large ($8). The medium exists primarily to make the large look like a bargain — only $1 more for a significant size increase. Digital menus can display these options with size-proportional graphics that make the upgrade visually obvious.

Upselling Strategies That Work

1. Combo and Bundle Promotion

Combos are the most straightforward upselling technique. Instead of letting customers order just an entree, you present a combo that includes a side and drink at a bundled price. The customer feels like they're getting a deal; you've increased the ticket by $4-6.

Digital menus excel at combo promotion because they can:

• Display combos with animated transitions that catch attention
• Show the "savings" visually (individual prices crossed out, combo price highlighted)
• Rotate different combo options throughout the day
• Feature seasonal combos that create urgency

2. Premium Item Spotlighting

Use a dedicated section of your digital display to spotlight premium items with larger images and compelling descriptions. "Chef's Special: Pan-seared salmon with seasonal vegetables — $22" with a beautiful photo will sell far more units than the same item buried in a text list on a printed menu.

Digital boards let you rotate the spotlight throughout the day — lunch special in the afternoon, signature cocktails during happy hour, dessert features after 7 PM.

3. Add-On Suggestions

Digital menus can display add-on suggestions near each category: "Add avocado +$2" next to the burger section, "Upgrade to sweet potato fries +$1.50" next to the sides. These micro-upsells are small enough that customers rarely object but add up significantly across hundreds of orders.

4. Time-Based Promotions

Schedule your digital menu to show different upselling content at different times:

• Morning: "Add a fresh pastry to your coffee — $3"
• Lunch: "Make it a combo with soup or salad — $4"
• Happy hour: "Half-price appetizers with any drink order"
• Dinner: "Start with our signature bruschetta — $9"
• Late night: "Dessert + coffee special — $8"

This happens automatically — no staff intervention needed. The menu adapts throughout the day to maximize upsell opportunities at each daypart.

5. Social Proof Displays

"Most Popular" and "Customer Favorite" labels are powerful upselling tools. People gravitate toward what others have chosen, especially when they're unfamiliar with a menu. Digital boards can highlight these items with badges, borders, or animations that draw the eye.

Some restaurants display real-time popularity: "27 ordered today" next to a featured item. This creates FOMO and encourages customers to try the highlighted dish.

6. Beverage Promotion

Drinks are high-margin items that often get overlooked when customers focus on food. A dedicated beverage section on your digital menu — with photos of craft cocktails, local beers, and fresh-made juices — reminds customers to order drinks they might otherwise skip.

For Sacramento restaurants, highlighting local brewery partnerships or farm-to-fork cocktails with seasonal ingredients taps into the local food culture that customers value.

Measuring Upselling Success

Digital menus make it possible to measure the impact of upselling strategies:

• Average ticket size: Track weekly averages before and after implementing digital menus
• Combo attach rate: What percentage of orders include a combo vs. individual items?
• Featured item sales: Do spotlighted items sell more than when they were just listed?
• Daypart performance: Are time-based promotions actually driving incremental sales?

A/B testing is one of digital menus' biggest advantages over printed menus. Test two different layouts, two different combo offers, or two different featured items — then keep what works.

Common Upselling Mistakes

Too Many Options

A cluttered menu with 80 items doesn't upsell — it overwhelms. Decision fatigue causes customers to default to the cheapest or most familiar option. Digital menus should be designed for clarity with strategic emphasis on high-margin items, not used to display every possible combination.

Aggressive Pricing Perception

If your upselling makes customers feel nickeled and dimed, it backfires. "Extra cheese +$1, extra sauce +$0.75, extra napkins +$0.50" creates resentment. Focus upselling on genuine value additions — larger portions, premium ingredients, complete meals — not on charging for basics.

Ignoring Menu Engineering Basics

Menu engineering — the strategic placement and pricing of items to maximize profitability — applies to digital menus just as much as printed ones. High-margin, high-popularity items (your "stars") should get the most prominent placement. Low-margin items shouldn't be featured in upselling displays.

Digital Menus as Part of Your Restaurant Strategy

Upselling through digital menus works best as part of a broader restaurant strategy that includes:

• Staff training — Digital menus complement verbal upselling, not replace it
• Strong online presence — Make sure customers find you first. Run a free SEO audit on your restaurant's website to check your search visibility
• Consistent branding — Your digital menu design should match your brand identity across all touchpoints
• Physical space optimization — The restaurant buildout matters too. Work with licensed local contractors to ensure your space is designed for the customer flow that supports upselling (clear sightlines to menu boards, comfortable ordering areas)

Real Numbers: The Impact of Digital Menu Upselling

Based on industry data and our clients' experience:

• Restaurants implementing digital menu upselling see 12-22% increases in average ticket size
• Combo attachment rates increase by 15-30% when visually promoted on digital boards
• Featured item sales increase by 20-35% compared to standard menu listing
• Beverage attach rates increase by 10-18% with dedicated digital beverage displays

For a restaurant averaging $25 per ticket and serving 200 customers per day, a 15% ticket increase means $750 in additional daily revenue — over $22,000 per month.